What if Guarma NEVER Happened? Red Dead Redemption 2

The Guarma chapter in Red Dead Redemption 2 is often considered a polarizing detour in the game. This unexpected tropical island journey, following the disastrous Saint Denis bank heist, shifts the focus away from the American frontier and thrusts the gang into a world of rebellion, exploitation, and survival. But what if Guarma had never been part of the story? How would Dutch's descent into paranoia, Arthur's physical decline, and the gang's unraveling have been impacted without this chapter?

In this video, we explore the potential consequences of removing Guarma from the game, analyzing how it accelerates character development, Dutch's breakdown, and Arthur's redemption arc. We also consider how the pacing and focus of the game might have shifted without the chaos and physical strain of Guarma. Would the gang’s inevitable collapse have been delayed? Could more content have been focused on internal conflicts and character-driven quests?

Join us as we examine how the Guarma chapter changes the trajectory of RDR2’s story and characters, and how the game might have played out without it. Let me know your thoughts in the comments below—don't forget to subscribe for more deep dives like this!