Karen Read's Voicemails, Texts & Timeline. Broken Taillight and John's Shoe found | Case Brief

Watch the full coverage of the live stream on ‪@TheEmilyDBaker‬ YouTube channel: https://youtube.com/live/r2vEF0vxG2w

Day 10 of the Karen Read Retrial happened on May 6, 2025. We finished up Cross Examination of Lt. Paul Gallagher, along with Re-Directs and Re-Cross. When he was clearing the area with the leaf blower, he never found a hat, a shoe, and red pieces of plastic tail lights. He was also questioned why he never got a search warrant to the premises of 34 Fairview Rd.

Meteorologist, Robert Gilman, testified next and talked about the ground being frozen, the amount of snow on the ground, and visibility conditions at the time of the incident. Defense Attorney Robert Alessi used this testimony to highlight the relatively little amount of snow and good visibility when John arrived at 34 Fairview Rd. The Meteorologist also brought up the concept of windchill to argue about the potential effect on O'Keefe's body and to question whether he could have died from the cold outside.

Video clips of Karen Read in interviews with media saying she could have clipped John in the leg were played tot he jury.

Trooper Nick Guarino was recalled to the stand for the final time to bring in timeline evidence of evidence of Karen Read's communication with John O'Keefe's cell phone around the time they arrived to 34 Fairview Rd. Missed calls, voice messages, and texts messages varied from angry and accusatory around midnight to panicked at towards the morning up until she found John O'Keefe's body. A key piece of evidence is that Karen Read's cell phone automatically connected to John O'Keefe's home Wi-Fi Router at 12:36am.

Lt. Charles Rae testified to going to 1 Meadows where John O'Keefe lived to do a wellness check on his niece and nephew. No one answered the door because by the time they arrived their, John's friends and family had already taken care of the kids. He was able to bring in footage from his dash cam showing Karen Read's SUV was at 1 Meadows and had a cracked tail light and some snow inside it.

Kevin O'Hara from SERT was brought in to testify about evidence recovery around 5pm on January 29th. Their focus was initially on the area near the road to avoid evidence being plowed away. Five to six pieces of tail light and a shoe were found near the curb line. O'Hara testified that a man in a hoodie from 34 Faireview came outside the house asked "Are you here for what happened earlier?" And O'Hara replied, "Yes." And then the person just went back inside.

Today's focus is on foundational testimony and evidence gathering, setting the stage for future discussions from accident reconstructionist. Though it was a less dramatic exchange between attorneys and witnesses than some previous days, how the jury will interpret the information, video clips and timeline presentation will impact the verdict.

RESOURCES
What You Need to Know About the Retrial -    • Karen Read Retrial. What you need to know ...  
Karen Read Retrial Playlist -    • Live Trials with Emily D. Baker  
Karen Read Trial - 2024 -    • Live Trials | Karen Read  - 2024 Mistrial  

THE DOCKET
0:00 Road So Far
1:55 ID Docuseries Clips
3:05 Trooper Guarino's Presentation
16:10 Lunch Summary
24:23 Dateline Interview
24:52 End of Day Summary


STAY IN THE LOOP WITH EMILY D. BAKER
Download Our FREE App: https://lawnerdapp.com
Get the Free Email Alert: https://www.LawNerdAlert.com
Case Requests & Business Inquiries: TeamEmilyDBaker@wmeagency.com
Help with the shop: https://www.lawnerdshop.com/pages/con...
Mailing Address: Emily D. Baker 2000 Mallory Ln. St. 130-185, Franklin TN 37067

LAW NERD MERCH!
https://www.LawNerdShop.com

LONG FORM CONTENT    / @theemilydbaker  
The Emily Show Podcast on YouTube: https://emilydbaker.com/TheEmilyShowP...
Apple Podcasts: https://emilydbaker.com/AppleTheEmily...
Spotify Podcasts: https://emilydbaker.com/SpofityTheEmi...
On your favorite podcast player Mondays


EMILY ON SOCIAL @TheEmilyDBaker
Instagram:   / theemilydbaker  
Twitter:   / theemilydbaker  
Facebook:   / theemilydbaker  

MY YOUTUBE TOOLS
**My Favorite YOUTUBE TOOL VidIQ https://vidiq.com/LawNerd

Follow My Cats on Instagram:
  / fredandgeorge_cat  

Emily’s glasses lenses are Irlen tint https://www.irlen.com

This video is not legal advice; it is commentary for educational and entertainment purposes. Some links shared are affiliate links, all sponsorships are stated in video. Videos are based on publicly available information unless otherwise stated. Sharing a resource is not an endorsement; it is a resource. Copyright 2020-2025 Baker Media, LLC