551 Prospect St, Maplewood, NJ

Welcome to 551 Prospect Street — a stunning Victorian that beautifully blends timeless architectural detail with thoughtful modern updates. Set on an almost ½-acre property with your own private wooded trails, this home offers a rare combination of historic elegance and serene, park-like living — just moments from Maplewood Village and the train to NYC.

Step onto the inviting mahogany front porch, perfect for morning coffee. Inside, the gracious foyer, reminiscent of a Brooklyn brownstone, features 2 large coat closets and original hardwood parquet floors. High ceilings and oversized windows throughout fill the home with natural light. The spacious living room with wood-burning fireplace and coffered ceiling, and sunlit dining room with beautiful windows set the stage for entertaining. The renovated kitchen with island opens to a large deck overlooking the fenced backyard and tranquil wooded lot beyond.

Upstairs are four bright bedrooms with newer Pella windows, oversized closets, and an extra-large linen closet. The renovated full bath with tub completes this level. The third-floor primary suite is a true retreat with vaulted ceilings, exposed beams, mini-split for added comfort, full bath with clawfoot soaking tub and tiled shower, plus 2 very generous closets. Finally, the partially finished basement boasts tall ceilings, laundry room, a full bath, and direct walk-out access to the serene backyard. A newer roof with warranty, and whole house water filter add to the upgrades.

This exceptional home captures the essence of Maplewood living — historic charm, modern updates, and a connection to nature in a central location.