Exploring the Controversies: Springboks vs. Ireland 2024 Referee Analysis

In this video, we take an in-depth look at the controversial referee decisions from the thrilling Springboks vs. Ireland match in 2024. Join us as we break down key moments, including disallowed tries and crucial calls, to understand what went right and what went wrong. Discover the intricacies of the game with insights on the decisions made by Referee Luke Pearce, Assistant Referees Mike Adamson and Karl Dickson, and TMO Ben Whitehouse.

From the disallowed try of James Lowe due to an overlooked neck roll to the controversial no-try call on Caelan Doris, we analyze every detail. We also cover the missed high tackle on Craig Casey that led to a significant injury and the ensuing controversial try by Cheslin Kolbe. Our analysis aims to shed light on these pivotal moments and spark a discussion on how officiating can improve in future matches.


00:00 - James Lowe Disallowed Try
02:07 - Craig Casey Injury
03:35 - Cheslin Kolbe Controversial Try
06:20 - Caelan Doris Disallowed Try
07:31 - Weird Missed Calls
09:08 - Inconsistencies At The Breakdown

Copyright and Fair Dealing Disclaimer
Under Section 12 of the Copyright Act No. 98 of 1978, as amended, allowance is made for “Fair Dealing” for purposes such as criticism or review. Fair Dealing is a use permitted by the Copyright Act that might otherwise be infringing.

The footage used in this video is the copyright of SuperSport International, who owns all rights in the use of such footage (whether as a licensee or not). The use of such footage by TASanalytics is solely in the context of Fair Dealing and TASanalytics does not assert any claim to, or ownership of the footage. TASanalytics is not an Affiliate of SuperSport International.

The views of TASanalytics or the makers of any videos on this channel are not those of SuperSport International (or its Affiliates).

No person or entity may repurpose or reuse any footage contained on this channel and a violation of such restriction may be considered a breach of the Copyright Act No. 98 of 1978, punishable by fine.

Attribution Tag
All footage used in this video is the copyright of SuperSport International who owns all rights in the use of such footage (whether as a licensee or not)and cannot be reused or repurposed without permission. The views of TASanalytics or the makers of any videos on this channel are not those of SuperSport International (or its Affiliates).