The first 500 people to use my link will get a 1 month free trial of Skillshare https://skl.sh/unsolicitedadvice05241
Over the years a consistent claim has emerged from both some theists and some atheists that morality is untenable without the existence of a God. But is this true? Today I will explore three variants on the position that "Atheists have no morals" to see which ones hold water and which are simply unfounded assumptions.
Support me on Patreon here: https://patreon.com/UnsolicitedAdvice...
Sign up to my email list for more philosophy to improve your life: https://forms.gle/YYfaCaiQw9r6YfkN7
Papers cited:
For claim that people harbour a distrust of atheists: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22059...
Benefits of group camping trips: https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/...
Relationship between religious attendance and generosity (an example of pro-social behaviour): https://news.gallup.com/poll/122807/r...
A paper questioning the relationship between atheism and pro-sociality. and the correlation sometimes found: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22925...
For Investigations between the religiosity of societies and their levels of anti-social behaviour: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Society-with...
Relationship between prosociality and religion: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38407....
On Atheists being more interested in consequentialist ethics and Theists being more interested in Group Cohesion: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/art...
Article on Moral Anti-Realism: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/mo...
00:00 God and Morality
01:20 "Atheists are Bad People"
07:57 "Morality Needs God"
14:09 The Atheist's Conundrum
19:09 Post-Theistic Morality
Поделиться в:
Доступные форматы для скачивания:
Скачать видео mp4
Информация по загрузке:
Скачать аудио mp3
Похожие видео
array(20) {
["5M6zXKNFgIo"]=>
object(stdClass)#7328 (5) {
["video_id"]=>
int(9999999)
["related_video_id"]=>
string(11) "5M6zXKNFgIo"
["related_video_title"]=>
string(57) "Evaluating Jordan Peterson's Strangest Religious Argument"
["posted_time"]=>
string(19) "1 год назад"
["channelName"]=>
NULL
}
["BHx6myLmgeY"]=>
object(stdClass)#7343 (5) {
["video_id"]=>
int(9999999)
["related_video_id"]=>
string(11) "BHx6myLmgeY"
["related_video_title"]=>
string(12) "Is God Evil?"
["posted_time"]=>
string(19) "1 год назад"
["channelName"]=>
NULL
}
["hic11P9-7XE"]=>
object(stdClass)#7329 (5) {
["video_id"]=>
int(9999999)
["related_video_id"]=>
string(11) "hic11P9-7XE"
["related_video_title"]=>
string(44) "Why Everyone is Wrong about Moral Relativism"
["posted_time"]=>
string(27) "5 месяцев назад"
["channelName"]=>
NULL
}
["N6RbsecxQ9Q"]=>
object(stdClass)#7326 (5) {
["video_id"]=>
int(9999999)
["related_video_id"]=>
string(11) "N6RbsecxQ9Q"
["related_video_title"]=>
string(64) "9 Questions Atheists CANNOT Answer - With @unsolicitedadvice9198"
["posted_time"]=>
string(19) "1 год назад"
["channelName"]=>
NULL
}
["GIQ1m2yXNI4"]=>
object(stdClass)#7321 (5) {
["video_id"]=>
int(9999999)
["related_video_id"]=>
string(11) "GIQ1m2yXNI4"
["related_video_title"]=>
string(143) "Как Зеленский попал в крупнейший коррупционный скандал своего президентства?"
["posted_time"]=>
string(22) "23 часа назад"
["channelName"]=>
NULL
}
["1FJHB45zMCw"]=>
object(stdClass)#7307 (5) {
["video_id"]=>
int(9999999)
["related_video_id"]=>
string(11) "1FJHB45zMCw"
["related_video_title"]=>
string(28) "Why Nietzsche HATED Religion"
["posted_time"]=>
string(19) "1 год назад"
["channelName"]=>
NULL
}
["982Aq8AnY64"]=>
object(stdClass)#7318 (5) {
["video_id"]=>
int(9999999)
["related_video_id"]=>
string(11) "982Aq8AnY64"
["related_video_title"]=>
string(78) "ПАНИКА В КИЕВЕ ❗ МИНИСТРЫ БЕГУТ В ЛОНДОН ❗"
["posted_time"]=>
string(21) "3 часа назад"
["channelName"]=>
NULL
}
["dTgBjl70vdg"]=>
object(stdClass)#7338 (5) {
["video_id"]=>
int(9999999)
["related_video_id"]=>
string(11) "dTgBjl70vdg"
["related_video_title"]=>
string(99) "Трофеи из украинского города в России (English subtitles) @Max_Katz"
["posted_time"]=>
string(21) "4 часа назад"
["channelName"]=>
NULL
}
["yWA12KbB4XA"]=>
object(stdClass)#7323 (5) {
["video_id"]=>
int(9999999)
["related_video_id"]=>
string(11) "yWA12KbB4XA"
["related_video_title"]=>
string(38) "The Argument Atheists Always Get Wrong"
["posted_time"]=>
string(19) "1 год назад"
["channelName"]=>
NULL
}
["OZyM4h2UEjc"]=>
object(stdClass)#7339 (5) {
["video_id"]=>
int(9999999)
["related_video_id"]=>
string(11) "OZyM4h2UEjc"
["related_video_title"]=>
string(55) "The Philosopher who Hated Everyone | Diogenes the Cynic"
["posted_time"]=>
string(19) "1 год назад"
["channelName"]=>
NULL
}
["LQK4Rmye4XU"]=>
object(stdClass)#7317 (5) {
["video_id"]=>
int(9999999)
["related_video_id"]=>
string(11) "LQK4Rmye4XU"
["related_video_title"]=>
string(182) "Удар по Зеленскому, фронт в движении, Россию отключили. Лавров «пропал», робот упал. Разбор новостей"
["posted_time"]=>
string(24) "10 часов назад"
["channelName"]=>
NULL
}
["Zmlr8LxWx9k"]=>
object(stdClass)#7327 (5) {
["video_id"]=>
int(9999999)
["related_video_id"]=>
string(11) "Zmlr8LxWx9k"
["related_video_title"]=>
string(51) "The Devil’s Terrifying Philosophy | Paradise Lost"
["posted_time"]=>
string(19) "1 год назад"
["channelName"]=>
NULL
}
["E1e7SsqO6a0"]=>
object(stdClass)#7322 (5) {
["video_id"]=>
int(9999999)
["related_video_id"]=>
string(11) "E1e7SsqO6a0"
["related_video_title"]=>
string(112) "ПРОХОР ШАЛЯПИН. Большое интервью с амбассадором легкой жизни"
["posted_time"]=>
string(19) "4 дня назад"
["channelName"]=>
NULL
}
["T-gRbVj3ebw"]=>
object(stdClass)#7319 (5) {
["video_id"]=>
int(9999999)
["related_video_id"]=>
string(11) "T-gRbVj3ebw"
["related_video_title"]=>
string(109) "Самый мощный ОБВАЛ у ВСУ! Сотни трупов! Военные сводки 14.11.2025"
["posted_time"]=>
string(24) "10 часов назад"
["channelName"]=>
NULL
}
["SxBwRAjTFcc"]=>
object(stdClass)#7320 (5) {
["video_id"]=>
int(9999999)
["related_video_id"]=>
string(11) "SxBwRAjTFcc"
["related_video_title"]=>
string(35) "Why the BEST Argument for God Fails"
["posted_time"]=>
string(27) "9 месяцев назад"
["channelName"]=>
NULL
}
["tqWXHpQYxYQ"]=>
object(stdClass)#7308 (5) {
["video_id"]=>
int(9999999)
["related_video_id"]=>
string(11) "tqWXHpQYxYQ"
["related_video_title"]=>
string(43) "Dostoevsky vs. Nietzsche | Philosophy Fight"
["posted_time"]=>
string(19) "1 год назад"
["channelName"]=>
NULL
}
["rAzg1XXy9I8"]=>
object(stdClass)#7309 (5) {
["video_id"]=>
int(9999999)
["related_video_id"]=>
string(11) "rAzg1XXy9I8"
["related_video_title"]=>
string(180) "Шойгу пытались убить? Бомба в Москве. Дудю дали срок. Алаудинов объявил чистки. Горит нефть | ВОЗДУХ"
["posted_time"]=>
string(21) "3 часа назад"
["channelName"]=>
NULL
}
["CLcDhJgmvuE"]=>
object(stdClass)#7315 (5) {
["video_id"]=>
int(9999999)
["related_video_id"]=>
string(11) "CLcDhJgmvuE"
["related_video_title"]=>
string(54) "Music, Mormonism and Peter Hitchens - 1.25 Million Q&A"
["posted_time"]=>
string(27) "8 месяцев назад"
["channelName"]=>
NULL
}
["6BzHMdTeQww"]=>
object(stdClass)#7316 (5) {
["video_id"]=>
int(9999999)
["related_video_id"]=>
string(11) "6BzHMdTeQww"
["related_video_title"]=>
string(82) "Philosopher and Preacher Go Head to Head on Morality, Evil, Consciousness and More"
["posted_time"]=>
string(23) "1 месяц назад"
["channelName"]=>
NULL
}
["VdGop8C_oGQ"]=>
object(stdClass)#7314 (5) {
["video_id"]=>
int(9999999)
["related_video_id"]=>
string(11) "VdGop8C_oGQ"
["related_video_title"]=>
string(0) ""
["posted_time"]=>
string(23) "1 месяц назад"
["channelName"]=>
NULL
}
}
