Your Calvinist: Keith Foskey on Comedy, Calvinism, Amillennialism & Cage-Stage Chaos

In this episode of the Reformark Media Show, we sit down with Keith Foskey pastor of Sovereign Grace Family Church, creator of the viral Your Calvinist channel, and one of the funniest, sharpest voices in Reformed media today.

From the origins of his skits, to the rise of his denomination characters, to why comedy belongs in the Christian life, this is one of our most entertaining and insightful interviews yet.

Keith shares:

• How “Your Calvinist” actually began
• The comedic sketch that launched his channel worldwide
• The role of humor in Christian community & discipleship
• Cage-stage Calvinism and cage-stage Roman Catholicism
• How to handle online critics and keep your pastoral authority
• What Calvinism really teaches
• Amillennialism explained simply, clearly, and hilariously
• How comedy and theology can thrive together

He also talks sponsorships, conferences, digital ministry, and what it means to remain faithful online and in the local church.

This episode is a blend of theology, comedy, history, and pastoral wisdom.

Website: keithfoskey.com

Youtube: Channel:   / @conversationswithacalvinist  

Chapters:
00:00 – Intro: Welcome to The Theo-Shed & Reformark Studio
00:35 – Who Is Keith Foskey? Background & Ministry
01:25 – Sewing Superhero Costumes & Childhood Stories
02:15 – Opening Prayer
03:00 – How “Your Calvinist” Got Started
07:00 – Early YouTube Days & Viral Benny Hinn Video
09:00 – COVID, Coffee With a Calvinist & Small Beginnings
11:00 – The Birth of Denomination Skits
13:00 – The 90,000-View Breakout Video
15:00 – Denominations Go Shooting — The Global Viral Moment
17:00 – Comedy as a Bridge for Reformed Theology
18:30 – On Doing Skits: Humor, Ministry & Creativity
20:00 – Reformark’s Comedy (“The X Wars”) & Digital Ministry
23:00 – Sponsors, Conferences & Behind-the-Scenes Growth
27:00 – Meeting People Through Conferences & Online Ministry
29:00 – What Calvinism Really Is
34:00 – Predestination, Evangelism & Callings
38:00 – Limited Atonement & Historical Theology
41:00 – God’s Will, Desire, & Difficult Passages Explained
46:00 – James, Peter & Contextual Exegesis
49:00 – Impressions, Ligonier & Spiritual Foundations
52:00 – Is Calvinism Cold? The Beauty of Reformed Theology
55:00 – Cage-Stage Catholics & Cage-Stage Protestants
58:00 – Navigating Online Tribalism & Discernment Culture
1:05:00 – pastoral guidance on book controversies (Nine Marks, SBC, etc.)
1:09:00 – Redeemed Zoomer, Friendship & Disagreement
1:13:00 – The Danger of “Guilt by Association”
1:18:00 – Amillennialism Explained
1:23:00 – Church Age, Satan Bound, & Revelation 20
1:29:00 – Postmill vs Amill: Similarities & Differences
1:32:00 – Practical Eschatology: Hope for the Church
1:37:00 – Humor, Sarcasm & Biblical Storytelling
1:45:00 – Dave Chappelle, Trans Ideology & Comedic Clarity
1:50:00 – Humor, Trust & Community in the Church
1:55:00 – Navigating Online Accusations & Pastoral Ministry
2:01:00 – Why Discernment Blogs Fail
2:03:00 – Redeemed Zoomer & Online Friendship
2:06:00 – The Mentors, Conferences & Voices That Shaped Us
2:10:00 – Where to Find Keith Foskey Online
2:11:00 – Speed Round (Calvinism, Scripture, Movies & More)
2:12:00 – Dad Joke Finale