Backlash erupts over Open Chats Podcast. What happens next?

We unpack the Open Chats Podcast controversy that’s ignited a storm across South Africa — from the racial slurs aimed at Coloured communities, to Gayton McKenzie’s explosive reaction and the legal firepower he’s mobilising. We explore the political fallout as parties and activists weigh in, We break down the legal possibilities, from crimen injuria charges to prosecution under South Africa’s new Hate Crimes and Hate Speech Act, and why they would be hard to invoke in the current circumstances following the apology by Open Chats hosts. But beyond the courtroom, we interrogate what this saga says about the persistence of racism in everyday conversation, the limits of free speech, and the broader struggle over dignity, representation, and accountability in our society.

Become a YouTube Member of SMWX:    / @_smwx  

Visit the SMWX store for merch and books: https://smwx.store

CONTACT:
✉️: info@smw-x.co.za
📞WhatsApp Line: 082 891 4935

Visit my website: sizwempofuwalsh.com

_______

Credits:
Director and DOP: Nomaan Haarzavi for Narr8 Studio
Lead Camera Operator: Faizan Haq for Narr8 Studio
2nd Camera Operator: Yusuf Rahman for Narr8 Studio
Producer: Oratile Kekana
_____

0:00 – Introduction
0:52 – What was said about coloured people
1:36 – Gayton McKenzie’s furious response
4:50 – Patriotic Alliance prepares legal action
5:10 – Liam Jacobs: “It hurts… we must act”
6:01 – Open Chats issues apology
7:48 – Why their legal team’s move may limit consequences
8:21 – ANC joins condemnation
9:10 – Could there be legal consequences?
10:02 – Criminal injuria explained
12:32 – Who can bring a case? The “standing” challenge
12:43 – Criminal injuria vs defamation
14:07 – How the Prevention of Hate Crimes Act works
15:21 – What counts as a hate crime
16:37 – Hate speech penalties and new legal powers
18:35 – Why criminal cases are hard to pursue
20:15 – Likely legal outcome for Open Chats
20:46 – Freedom of speech vs racial harm
22:19 – Should age and inexperience matter in penalties?
23:20 – How big is the Open Chats podcast?
25:06 – What this says about South Africa today
26:53 – Personal reflections on race and unity
27:59 – The deeper project beyond racial division
28:26 – Hopes for education and reconciliation
28:52 – Why a “silly” comment reveals bigger issues
29:05 – Wrapping up — the importance of swift accountability
30:00 – Like, share, subscribe — final thoughts
30:16 – Behind the scenes: Blooper