5 Chilling True Crime Cases That Still Haunt Colorado

Step into the chilling world of unresolved mysteries with "5 True Crime Cases in Colorado." These five haunting stories remain clouded in uncertainty, leaving families and communities yearning for answers and justice.

🕒 Case Lineup – 5 Chilling True Crime Stories (Colorado)
🔹 Jacob Scott Brady — A former high-school athlete from Louisiana with a love for the outdoors reinvents himself as a model, splitting time between home and Colorado while building a new life tied to hiking trails, live music, and a close circle of friends. After returning to Denver in 2021, Jacob is found shot and killed in a quiet residential neighborhood the day after Thanksgiving. With little public information released and his case quickly overshadowed by other violence that same weekend, the circumstances surrounding his death—and who is responsible—remain unclear years later.
🔹 Marjorie Sue Fithian — A young mother from Greeley travels to Denver with her toddler for what should have been a routine family visit, planning to return home by bus just days later. On the morning of their departure, Marjorie and her son are dropped off at the station—but they never board. Hours later, in a remote stretch of Weld County ranch land, a horrifying scene is discovered along a gravel road. Despite early witness sightings and reports of a suspicious vehicle, the trail quickly grows cold, leaving questions that have lingered for decades.
🔹 Pamela Lynne Neal — A quiet, artistic young woman returns to Colorado after years of travel and adventure, settling into a steady routine with an apartment just steps from work. One spring afternoon, she leaves on her lunch break to run a few simple errands and is seen entering her apartment as expected. When she never returns, concern quickly turns to alarm. Inside her home, everything appears untouched—groceries on the table, personal belongings left behind, no sign of a struggle. Pamela vanishes without a trace, leaving behind one of Englewood’s most haunting mysteries.
🔹 Richard Glen Beebe — A retired businessman in his seventies disappears from Denver after a quiet life shared with a roommate, leaving behind nearly all of his belongings, including his medication and phone. Days later, his car is discovered abandoned miles away. Soon after, his family receives a message claiming Richard has left the state for good—but those closest to him say the message doesn’t sound like him at all. With conflicting timelines and no physical trace of what happened next, his disappearance remains deeply unsettling.
🔹 Sheryl Parker — A devoted mother and longtime Fort Collins resident disappears after leaving home one summer night following a tense argument. In the days that follow, fragments of her final movements surface—an ATM stop, a motel stay miles from home, and a vehicle left behind. Less than a week later, Sheryl is found dead in a nearby river. With limited physical evidence and critical questions left unanswered, the truth about what happened to her has remained elusive for nearly three decades.

🔍 Uncover the Details:
Explore the timelines, key evidence, and unanswered questions surrounding these gripping cases. Could you hold the missing piece of the puzzle? Share your theories in the comments and join the conversation!

💡 Stay Engaged:
👉 Subscribe for weekly true crime videos: https://www.youtube.com/c/SouthernGir...
👉 Explore our unsolved cases playlist:    • Unsolved Mysteries: True Crime Cases  
👉 Have a case suggestion? Email us: southerngirlcrimestories@gmail.com

Support the Channel:
👉 Support us on Patreon:   / southerngirlcrimestories  
☕ Support the channel on Buy Me a Coffee: https://www.buymeacoffee.com/southerngi8

Donations:
👉 PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted...
👉 Venmo: www.venmo.com/u/southerngirlcrimestories

📚 Sources:
https://controlc.com/ebe63333

📺 YouTube Chapters
🔹 00:00 – Jacob Scott Brady: Found Shot After Thanksgiving
🔹 02:17 – Marjorie Sue Fithian: A Bus Trip Never Taken
🔹 07:54 – Pamela Lynne Neal: Vanished From Her Apartment
🔹 12:48 – Richard Glen Beebe: A Message That Wasn’t Him
🔹 16:29 – Sheryl Parker: Last Movements Before the River

#truecrimediscussion #UnsolvedCases #CrimeStories #coldcases #JusticeForVictims #TrueCrimeCommunity #Colorado