Grant Stone Boots Disappointment? Honest Review & Alternatives

In this episode of the Prime Dude Podcast, I dive into my first-ever Grant Stone boots review — and let’s say, the experience was not what I expected. These boots are praised in the men’s fashion and menswear world for their Goodyear welt construction, quality leathers, and American brand heritage. But after unboxing the Grant Stone Edward boot in olive calfskin, I found some serious issues with quality control that left me questioning whether they’re worth the $400+ price tag.

I’ll walk you through:
My unboxing and first impressions of the Edward boot on the Leo last
Fit and sizing guidance (why going half-size down matters)
Leather quality from Charles F. Stead, and where it fell short
Visible scratches, dents, and stitching flaws out of the box
Why I ultimately decided to return them

I also compare Grant Stone to other bootmakers I’ve worn — including Allen Edmonds, BLKBRD Shoemaker, and Meermin — and share my thoughts on suede boots for fall and winter, such as the Meermin chukka inspired by James Bond. Finally, I conclude on a high note with a pair of Allen Edmonds Dalton boots I scored on eBay, proving that there are still great deals to be found.
If you’re into men’s style tips, menswear reviews, or want to know the truth about Grant Stone boots, don’t miss this one.

🔹 Chapters
0:00 Intro – Why today’s show is about boots
0:35 My first Grant Stone unboxing
2:25 Edward boot details: leather, welt, and last
3:45 Fit, sizing guidance, and first issues
5:40 Scratches, dents, and quality control problems
7:55 Why I decided to return these boots
9:30 Comparing Grant Stone vs BLKBRD, Allen Edmonds, and Meermin
11:05 Suede boots for fall & winter (Meermin chukka review)
12:50 Shell Cordovan & eBay finds (Alden & more)
13:55 Allen Edmonds Dalton boots — ending on a positive note
15:30 Coming next week: best pants for fall & winter