The Disturbing Truth Behind Rudolph The Red Nosed Reindeer They Never Taught You

You know Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer as the beloved Christmas story about a misfit reindeer who saves Christmas and is finally accepted.

Watch Next:
The Disturbing Truth Behind A Christmas Carol They Never Taught You -    • The Disturbing Truth Behind A Christmas Ca...  
The Disturbing Truth Behind Silent Night They Never Taught You -    • The Disturbing Truth Behind Silent Night T...  
The Disturbing Truth Behind Christmas They Never Taught You -    • The Disturbing Truth Behind Christmas They...  

But Rudolph isn't ancient folklore passed down through generations—he was created in 1939 by a desperate Montgomery Ward copywriter named Robert L. May whose wife was dying of cancer, leaving him drowning in medical debt and crushing depression.

The department store needed a cheap Christmas giveaway book to compete with rivals, so May—working through his wife's final illness and death—created a story about a bullied, ostracized reindeer rejected by his own parents. He later admitted Rudolph was himself: the outcast who didn't belong, watching his family collapse under tragedy while trying to appear normal at work. The original story was darker than what we know today—Rudolph's parents were ashamed of him, the other reindeer violently excluded him, and Santa only valued him when he became useful on a foggy Christmas Eve.

Then in 1949, May's brother-in-law Johnny Marks sanitized it into the song we all know, adding the false redemption ending where the reindeer genuinely loved Rudolph. In the original, they only tolerated him because Santa said so. The 1964 Rankin/Bass TV special sanitized it even further, turning a story born from grief and depression into cheerful family entertainment. Montgomery Ward gave away millions of copies, but kept all the rights—May stayed poor for eight years despite creating a cultural phenomenon, finally receiving the copyright in 1947 as a Christmas gift from the company president.

Today, Rudolph is a billion-dollar franchise. But the hidden message remains: being different is only acceptable if you're profitable. Santa doesn't defend Rudolph from bullying—he uses him when convenient. The other reindeer don't learn empathy—they learn to respect usefulness. This is corporate America's perfect metaphor, created by a man in unimaginable pain and sold back to us as holiday cheer.

In this video, we reveal:
→ Robert L. May's personal tragedy: wife dying of cancer while creating Rudolph (1938-1939)
→ Why Montgomery Ward commissioned the story (cost-saving measure, not creative inspiration)
→ The original 1939 story: parents ashamed, reindeer cruel, conditional acceptance
→ How May wrote Rudolph as a coping mechanism for his own depression and isolation
→ The copyright battle: May owned nothing for 8 years, stayed poor despite millions of books distributed
→ Johnny Marks's 1949 song: how it sanitized the trauma and added false redemption
→ The 1964 Rankin/Bass special: further sanitization, new characters, happy parents
→ The hidden corporate message: you're only valuable if you're useful to authority
→ May's final years and what he really thought about his creation
→ The billion-dollar franchise built on one man's grief

Robert L. May created Rudolph while sitting at his dying wife's hospital bedside. Every time he heard the song in his final years, he cried. We sing about acceptance and belonging, but the story was always about conditional value and profitable differences.

🔔 Subscribe for more disturbing truths hidden in Christmas traditions
💬 What other "heartwarming" Christmas stories have dark origins? Comment below.

SOURCES & FURTHER READING:
Robert L. May biographical records and interviews
Montgomery Ward Archives (1939-1947)
Original 1939 "Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer" manuscript
Johnny Marks estate and song copyright records
Rankin/Bass Productions history
May family interviews and memoirs

#Rudolph #RudolphTheRedNosedReindeer #ChristmasHistory #DarkOrigins #MontgomeryWard #RobertLMay #ChristmasTraditions #RudolphOrigin #DisturbingTruth #ChristmasStory #RudolphDarkHistory #1939Christmas #ChristmasCarol #HolidayHistory #ChristmasMythology #RudolphRealStory #VintageChristmas #ChristmasLore