Clare/Eli/Imogen♥ Better Than Revenge

Clare thought her relationship with Eli would never end. But she starts to notice Eli developing an interest in Imogen and feels Imogen is stealing Eli away. When Clare spots Eli and Imogen the first time, she confronts Eli who simply explains "Imogen is just a friend." But that same day Clare spots them spending lunch together acting a little too friendly. While Clare is in class, Imogen and Eli skip and meet in the theatre room. Imogen gives Eli the option of having two girlfriends....with the intention of eventually getting Clare out of the picture. After School Clare and Eli meet at The Dot for coffee. Clare brings up Eli and Imogen both missing from class after lunch. Before Eli realizes, the lies start forming and he tells Clare, Imogen got sick and they spent all of class in the nurses office. Not entirely convinced, Clare attempts to befriend Imogen at school and has lunch with her the following afternoon. Instead of getting to know imogen, to Clare's surprise Imogen shared her feelings for Eli as if they were no secret and warned Clare she wouldn't win. Pissed, the next morning Clare gives Eli an ultimatum. Either Eli stops hanging around Imogen or Eli is going to lose Clare. Before Eli has a chance to make a choice, Imogen catches him before class and convinces him to ditch class with her. one thing leads to another...and they end up in Eli's bed. After Clare gets home she calls Eli and calls him out on skipping class with Imogen and breaks up with him. The next day at lunch Imogen simply tells Clare "he was mine before you even lost him." Annoyed, Clare decides to play Imogens game and plans to steal Eli back. Finding Eli before class Clare tells him she didn't mean what she said on the phone with him yesterday and asks if he'll take he back. Caught off guard, Eli immediately takes Clare back. However dinner stirs up drama when Imogen crashes what was meant to be a dinner date for Eli and Clare. Caught in between a cat fight over him, Eli rushes out of the resturant. Later Imogen shows up at Eli's house and apologizes and the make up turns into a make out. At school the next morning, Imogen confronts Clare and apologizes to her for reuining Clare and Eli's date. Now that Imogen and Eli spending time together isnt a secret to Clare, Imogen no longer views the relationship as a game...she genuinely wants to be with Eli because he makes her happy. But now it's a game to Clare. Clare just wants to give Imogen a taste of her own medicine. But in Drama class Clare witnesses Imogen and Eli having a moment and realizes she can't win. In defeat Clare storms out telling Eli she's done with him and Imogen and him deserve eachother. Noticing how hurt Eli was after Clare left him, Imogen felt hurt that she didnt mean as much to him as Clare did. After class Eli apologizes to Imogen and tells her he only wants to be with her. Imogen forgives Eli and tells him she'll think about his offer. But as she walks away with a smile, its clear to both what she'll choose. At lunch the next day Eli and Imogen confront Clare and Thank her, for without her, they probably wouldn't be together.