Buffalo Trace Tier List: The Definitive Ranking

We ranked a large portion of Buffalo Trace products—from the ultra-rare Pappy 23 to the budget-friendly Benchmark—and no bottle was safe. This is the brutally honest Buffalo Trace Tier List, with 34 bottles placed from S-Tier to “What were they thinking?”

If you’ve ever wondered which Buffalo Trace releases actually live up to the hype—and which ones you can skip—this video is your complete guide. From cult classics like Blanton’s and Weller Full Proof to the lesser-known Kosher lineup, we’re calling it like we see it.

👉 Watch 'til the end to see which bottles really earned a top-tier rating—and which ones landed in the dreaded D-Tier.

👇 Drop your own rankings in the comments—we know you’ve got opinions.

🔥 NEW MERCH DROP! 🔥
Rep the Barrel Hunters in style! Shirts, glasses, and more now available in our official store: https://shop.barrelhunters.com/
👕🥃🎯

🔔 Subscribe to get all our latest whiskey updates!    / @barrelhuntersatx  

FOLLOW US!!

  / barrelhuntersatx  
  / barrelhuntersatx  
  / barrelhuntersatx  
https://www.x.com/barrel_hunters

#BuffaloTrace
#WhiskeyTierList
#BourbonRanking
#WhiskeyReview
#PappyVanWinkle
#Weller
#EHtaylor
#BourbonHype
#Sazerac
#WhiskeyTube
#BourbonHunters
#BarrelHunters
#BourbonTasting
#Blantons
#BourbonCollectors