Is the Second Amendment Really a Second-Class Right? 💥🔫

The Second Amendment guarantees the right to keep and bear arms, but are all rights created equal? Is the Second Amendment unfairly cast as a second-class right?

This provocative claim is far from new – gun rights advocates, scholars, and even judges have argued the point for years. The 2nd class right claim has even found its way into landmark Supreme Court cases, like NYSRPA v. Bruen and McDonald v. City of Chicago. At the heart of these arguments lies a nagging worry: the Second Amendment might not be granted the same level of protection as other constitutional rights. To cut through the noise, we turned to Prof. Joseph Blocher (Duke Law School) for expert insight.

The crux of the second-class right claim may very well stem from the historical lack of judicial review concerning gun laws in the U.S. Prof. Blocher reveals that for over two centuries, not a single federal gun law was struck down by any court across the country on 2nd Amendment grounds. This surprising fact has helped to fuel the perception that the Second Amendment is (or at least was) a second-class right.

After the groundbreaking DC v. Heller case in 2008, which established the individual right to keep guns, courts have started to scrutinize gun laws with newfound rigor. Yet, even with this increased scrutiny, few regulations have been struck down on Second Amendment constitutional grounds. Some argue this indicates courts still aren't enforcing the Second Amendment. On the other hand, perhaps the low success rate of challenges simply reflects a lack of gun laws to challenge. Prof Blocher explores the numbers.

The Bill of Rights enshrines some of the most cherished constitutional freedoms for Americans, but the order of the list doesn't imply ranking. The Second Amendment may clash with other rights, but there's no clear hierarchy. The First Amendment, for instance, doesn't always take precedence over the Second. Blocher emphasizes that the crucial question isn't about ranking but rather whether the Second Amendment is being rigorously applied according to its intended meaning.

► https://www.talksonlaw.com/briefs/is-...
► http://www.talksonlaw.com for more legal explainers and interviews with the titans of law.


____________________
0:10 Introduction of gun law expert, Prof. Blocher
0:34 Why do some suggest the 2nd Amendment is treated as inferior?
1:43 Is there a constitutional ranking of rights in the Bill of Rights?
2:25 Some rights have more strict tests than others
3:00 Treatment of 2A before DC v. Heller
5:15 Treatment of 2A after Heller
6:25 The Success Rate of Challenges to Gun Laws
6:54 Is the 1st Amendment Given Priority over the 2nd Amendment?