What's The Best Enduro Pedal? Crankbrothers VS. Shimano MTB Clip Pedals | Eric's Test Kitchen ep.3

After six years of riding Shimano clipless pedals, I decided it was time for a change. In this episode of Eric's Test Kitchen, we’re diving into the great pedal debate: Crankbrothers vs. Shimano. I’ll break down the pros and cons of both systems, test them head-to-head on the trails, and explain why I finally made the switch.

Whether you’re a die-hard Shimano rider, a loyal Crankbrothers fan, or just curious about the difference, this video has the insights you need to make an informed decision. As always, expect some classic Test Kitchen humor and mountain bike action!

Pedals Tested:

Shimano XT, XTR, PD-ME700
Crankbrothers Mallet DH, Mallet E, Candy

What I Cover:

Engagement and release feel
Durability and maintenance
Float and adjustability

Let me know your thoughts in the comments. Are you Team Shimano or Team Crankbrothers?

Subscribe for more MTB gear reviews, trail tips, and kitchen-themed MTB shenanigans.

0:00 Intro
0:35 Cleats
1:10 Clip Mechanism
1:45 Clip In Feel
2:16 Mud Performance
2:43 Durability
3:00 Pedal Bearing Design
3:34 Contact/Shoe Support
4:00 Common Wear Problem on Shimano
4:21 Pedal Feel
5:06 Ziptie Pro Hack for Shimano
5:44 Bikepacking Knee Pain Interlude
6:20 Longevity/Maintenance/Serviceability
6:48 Shimano Bent Axle/Spindle Warranty
7:24 Spare Parts Shimano
7:59 Spare Parts Crankbrothers
9:27 Crankbrothers Spindle/Axle Durability
9:38 Ergonomics/My Preference/Knee Pain
11:00 Pro Racer Preferences
11:23 Conclusion