Who -- or What -- Was I Dating? | True Scary Dating Stories Compilation | Spooky Scary Storytime

Who or What Was I Dating? | Scary Dating Stories Compilation | Spooky Scary Storytime

They say love is blind… but in these stories, it might also be cursed.

In this eerie Spooky Scary Storytime compilation, three listeners share chilling experiences that began as romance, but quickly spiraled into something supernatural, unsettling, or just downright strange.


Story 1: The Bookstore Stranger
A woman in Charleston, North Carolina meets a charming man who frequents the bookstore where she works. But when he reveals unsettling details about her family’s past, she realizes he may have known her long before they ever met.

Story 2: The Night Walker in the Woods
April thought she was falling for a quiet, mysterious man who lived deep in the forest. But his late-night disappearances, strange behaviors, and animalistic instincts suggested he was hiding something... not entirely human.

Story 3: The Airport Connection
After meeting a man in the Denver airport and beginning a long-distance relationship, Amara starts receiving disturbing phone calls from her own number. What begins as love turns into a high-strangeness nightmare she can’t explain.

Welcome to Spooky Scary Storytime
This is a place where real people share unbelievable but true experiences: paranormal encounters, unsolved mysteries, strange synchronicities, and the creepiest dating stories you’ll ever hear. We believe you.

📲 Follow me on TikTok and Instagram @ashleeinc for daily scary stories
🔗 Submit your own story or get more info: https://dogoodstaybad.com

#datinghorrorstories #scarystorytime #supernaturalromance #creepyex #paranormalencounters #spookystories #ashleeinc #weirdtiktok #truehorrorstories #spooky #storytime #creepycompilation #werewolfstory #haunting #ghoststory #strangerthings