"Happily Ever After" S14E01 💀 Horror Hill (Scary Stories Creepypasta Podcast)

Welcome to a new season of Horror Hill, where the ordinary slips, cracks, and reveals the nightmare beneath. In this premiere episode, host Erik Peabody invites you into the mind-bending world of acclaimed author J.R. Hamantaschen, whose tales twist everyday moments into something jagged and uncanny. Tonight’s story begins with something familiar—a promising date, a quiet restaurant, a heartbeat of hope—and then takes a hard turn into territory no one could have prepared for. What unfolds is a razor-edged descent into panic, absurdity, and the unexpected horrors of being human. Equal parts darkly funny and deeply unsettling, this episode explores what happens when the smallest anxieties meet forces far beyond our control. Monsters may come in many forms… and some of them are wearing very familiar faces.

▬ LISTEN TO THIS EPISODE AD-FREE IN OUR PATRONS AREA ▬
🗝️ https://www.chillingtalesfordarknight...

TURN OFF THE LIGHTS, AND TURN ON THE DARK.

⏮️ PREVIOUS EPISODE "The Colossus" Horror Hill S13E24:
   • "The Colossus" S13E24 💀 Horror Hill (Scary...  

⚠️ Skip the intro: 3:43

⏰ NAVIGATION / FEATURED STORIES:
✦ 00:00 - Episode Start
✦ 03:55 - “I’m a Good Person, I Mean Well, and I Deserve Better” by J.R. Hamantaschen (performed by Erik Peabody)

PODCAST EPISODE SUMMARY

“I’m a Good Person, I Mean Well, and I Deserve Better” — Bryce is convinced he’s finally on the right track: a promising fourth date, a woman he genuinely likes, and a cozy restaurant that feels like the start of something real. Then a sudden, excruciatingly ill-timed bathroom emergency shatters his composure—just as a recently fired line cook arrives with an impossible new power to manifest monsters from his own twisted imagination. As the evening spirals into a grotesque collision of bodily humiliation, nostalgic nightmare creatures, and desperate attempts to stay alive (or at least dignified), this darkly comic horror story lays bare the fragile myths we tell ourselves about being “good people” who deserve better.

▬ HEAR MORE OF NARRATOR ERIK PEABODY ▬
⚰️️ Official CTFDN Erik Peabody Playlist:    • "R.I.P. Ellen" CTFDN Original Creepypasta ...  
⚰️️ Official Horror Hill Podcast Playlist:    • "Childhood Memories" S11E17 💀 Horror Hill ...  

PODCAST EPISODE CREDITS
Hosted by: Erik Peabody
Stories Written by: J.R. Hamantaschen
Stories Performed by: Erik Peabody
Stories Produced and Mastered by: Erik Peabody
Host Script by: Erik Peabody
Episode Artwork: Craig Groshek
Video Render by: Craig Groshek
Logo and Podcast Concept: Craig Groshek

▬ ALL OF OUR LINKS ▬
🌐 https://linktr.ee/chillingtalesfordar...

🔔 SUBSCRIBE FOR MORE SCARY STORIES 🔔
✦ Chilling Tales for Dark Nights: https://bit.ly/3Oc7vCl
✦ Otis Jiry's Horror Storytime: https://bit.ly/4fnwBuc

▬ BECOME A PATRON, AND GET OUR CONTENT 100% AD-FREE ▬
⚡ https://www.chillingtalesfordarknight...

▬ HELP SUPPORT US ▬
🎃 Buy Our Horror Anthology Book on Amazon: https://amzn.to/3zzkiLP
💚GoFundMe: https://bit.ly/48LJP1b
💙 PayPal: https://www.paypal.com/biz/profile/ch...

▬ SUBMIT YOUR OWN STORIES ▬
📝 Email: [email protected]
📝 Website: https://www.creepypastastories.com/su...

▬ OUR WEBSITES ▬
🔗 Chilling Tales for Dark Nights: https://www.chillingtalesfordarknight...
🔗 The Simply Scary Podcast Network: https://www.simplyscarypodcast.com
🔗 Creepypasta Stories: https://www.creepypastastories.com

▬ RECOMMENDED PLAYLISTS ▬
🎃 Creepy Compilations (Story Collections and Anthologies):    • Creepy Compilations (Horror Anthologies / ...  
🎃 Horror a la Carte (Individual / Stand-alone Stories):    • Horror a la Carte (Individual Horror Story...  

#horrorstories #horrorstory #scarystories #truescarystories #creepypasta #nosleep #creepypastas #creepypastastories #creepypastastory #horror #scary #scarystory #creepystories #creepystory #truestories #asmr #horroraudiobook #paranormal #radiotheater #horrorpodcast #podcast #audiobook #horrorstorypodcast #ctfdn #chillingtalesfordarknights #chillingtales #horrorhill #horrorhillpodcast #erikpeabody #anthology #horroranthology