Field Day Disappointment? Why We Think ARRL Needs to Evolve (+ FTX1 Final Update)

What happens when the "Super Bowl of Amateur Radio" meets poor band conditions? The Everyday Ham team breaks down their 2025 ARRL Field Day experience with honest reflection about what worked, what didn't, and why it still matters.


Despite challenging propagation that made 20 meters nearly useless, our South Lyon Area Amateur Radio Club (SLAARC) field operation managed 680 QSOs with 16 operators including several first-timers making their debut HF contacts. The camaraderie and mentorship moments proved more memorable than any score could reflect.


Our equipment choices sparked fascinating discussion about the evolution of field operations. We deployed simple yet effective antennas including Aerial-51 off-center fed dipoles on SOTA-beam masts and a remarkable military surplus 40-meter vertical built from scrap aluminum by silent key Larry K8UT that outperformed expectations. All stations used FTDX10 radios - a choice we explain after detailing our final journey away from problematic FTX1 models and praising Ham Radio Outlet's exceptional customer service.


The most thought-provoking segment explores whether POTA is replacing traditional Field Day. With outdoor portable operation now happening year-round, we question how ARRL might evolve Field Day to maintain relevance, particularly addressing the controversial 1D station rules. An 82-year-old ham's perspective that "POTA is the future of ham radio" launches us into examining the balance between contesting, emergency practice, and social connection.


Join us for laughs about Jim's abandoned attempt to backpack a DX10 to Mackinac Island, heated debates about "please copy" Field Day etiquette, and news about our exciting guest for Episode 8 - someone from one of the "big three" manufacturers you won't want to miss!


Subscribe: https://www.everydayham.com


If you enjoy the Everyday Ham Podcast, please leave a five-star review - it helps others find us and keeps this conversation growing.


Short show intro audio clip


Short outro audio clip


The Everyday Ham Podcast is hosted by James Mills (K8JKU), Jim Davis (N8JRD), and Rory Locke (W8KNX) – three friends who dive into the world of amateur radio with a casual, lighthearted twist.


Follow us at: Website: https://www.everydayham.com/


Instagram:   / everydayhampodcast