Classical Republicanism vs. Liberalism: America’s Lost Balance

Why does U.S. politics feel like performance? This explainer argues it’s because we’ve clung to the democracy half (elections, parties, spectacle) and forgotten the republic—the concrete tools that let citizens govern between elections.

We trace the tension the Founders tried to balance: classical republicanism (common good, civic duty) vs. liberalism (individual rights, limited government). Through crises—the Whiskey Rebellion, Civil War, Great Depression, and Civil Rights era—federal power expanded and parties flipped positions to keep power. The result: a televised pageant of “the party of actors.”

But the republic isn’t gone—it’s unused. The Citizen’s Arsenal still exists:

Initiative/Referendum (write laws, gather signatures, go straight to the ballot)

Recall (fire officials mid-term)

Civil Grand Juries (citizen investigations of local government, in some states)

Transparency/FOIA/Sunshine laws (compel disclosure)

The real contest isn’t Left vs. Right; it’s Memory vs. Amnesia. Will we remember how to use the tools already written into law?

Chapters
00:00 The Pageant
01:22 Republic vs. Democracy (Founding balance)
03:00 Whiskey Rebellion & crisis centralization
04:45 Party flips over time
06:00 The Citizen’s Arsenal (how it works)
07:30 The real fight: Memory

#civics #republic #founders #foia #directdemocracy #history #politics

Read full text: https://archive.org/details/the-third...

Order Hardcopy: https://a.co/d/cqRHHeC