The History and Debate of High Tails Versus Low Tails in Pointing Dogs

In this episode, Craig Koshyk explores two distinct perspectives on pointing dog tails—whether they should be held high or low. What might seem like a minor detail sparks a deeper debate shaped by centuries of breeding, cultural differences, and shifting hunting styles. Craig takes us back in time through research, art, photographic evidence, and written accounts from the early years of pointing dogs. He expands on his own personal experiences, from Europe to the United States, and offers theories on how and why these differences—and the strong opinions surrounding them—persist today.

Parts of this history have broader implications, including the crossbreeding of not just various hunting dog breeds but even hounds. It prompts us to think long and hard about whether the tail truly matters—and when it does, why it matters at all.

📍 Timestamps:
00:00 Introduction and opening thoughts on tail position in pointing dogs
02:10 Historical context and early perspectives on tail carriage
04:20 Influence of European traditions and early breed standards
06:40 American hunting styles and their impact on tail preference
08:55 The shift toward high tails in field trial fashion
11:07 The growing popularity of high-tailed dogs in the U.S.
13:12 Early champions and the controversy around tail height
15:17 Field trial influence and the emergence of iconic sires
17:47 Cultural shifts and how handlers shaped perceptions
20:41 The lasting impact of field trial standards on tail position
23:41 Crossbreeding strategies and the introduction of new traits
26:41 How judges and handlers shaped visual expectations
30:11 Irish setters, red dogs, and the pursuit of the perfect tail
32:41 Genetic bottlenecks and the role of outcrossing
35:07 How form and fashion continue to shape pointing dog preferences
36:12 Europe vs. North America: the growing divide in breed standards
37:17 The irony of tail importance and what really matters in the field
38:23 Closing thoughts and where tradition meets function

Learn more about Hunting dogs: https://projectupland.com/category/hu...

Get Craig Koshyk's Books: https://projectupland.com/product-cat...