Castaway Cay vs Perfect Day at CocoCay!

After 20+ visits to both islands, we're settling the ultimate cruise debate: Disney's Castaway Cay vs Royal Caribbean's Perfect Day at CocoCay - which is worth your money?

/// Plan, book and earn free travel rewards on your next Disney cruise here ///
https://famvia.com/cruises/disney-cru...

/// Plan, book and earn free travel rewards on your next Royal Caribbean cruise here ///
https://famvia.com/cruises/royal-cari...

/// Become a Disney Cruise Line Travel Agent ///
https://vacationlab.io/learn/how-to-b...

/// Become a Royal Caribbean Cruise Line Travel Agent ///
https://vacationlab.io/learn/how-to-b...

/// Watch our Top 40 Questions Answered video all about Disney Cruise Line ///
   • 40 Tips for the Best Disney Cruise Experience  

/// Chapters ///
00:00 - Intro
00:27 - Castaway Cay Overview
03:46 - Perfect Day at Coco Cay Overview
07:19 - First Impressions
09:29 - From Ship to Play
11:17 - Beach Quality
12:10 - Free Water Fun (Ocean)
13:44 - Free Water Fun (Land)
15:30 - Paid Water Fun
16:15 - Free Food Options
17:27 - Ice Cream Options
19:01 - Paid Food Options
20:05 - Food Value
21:33 - Drinks Deals
22:48 - Fun for Littles
25:15 - Fun for Kids
26:07 - Fun for Tweens/Teens
27:27 - Adult Only Options
29:32 - Characters
30:12 - Entertainment
30:55 - Adventure Options
32:32 - Cabana Value
35:05 - Photo Opportunities
36:53 - Poor Weather
38:25 - Planning
39:21 - Do I Feel Lost
40:38 - Hidden Costs
42:18 - Crowd Level
44:51 - # of Itineraries to Get to the Island
46:25 - Accessibility & Special Needs
48:04 - Souvenir Shopping
49:39 - Transportation Around the Island
51:35 - Overall Family Value
53:54 - Winner (by Score)
54:48 - Winner (from the Kids)

What else you'll find in this video
Planning a cruise with a private island stop? This comprehensive comparison covers everything families need to know about Disney's Castaway Cay versus Royal Caribbean's Perfect Day at CocoCay. We break down 30 detailed categories including free activities, hidden costs, food quality, kids' entertainment, and adult-only areas. Discover which island offers better value for thrill-seekers, budget-conscious families, and Disney fans. Our honest review includes real spending breakdowns for families of four, accessibility features, and insider tips for maximizing your island day. From Daredevil's Peak waterslides to Disney character meet-and-greets, we've tested every major attraction and amenity. Learn about advance booking strategies, crowd management, and weather contingencies. Whether you're choosing between Disney Cruise Line and Royal Caribbean, or planning your first private island experience, this head-to-head comparison provides unbiased insights from seasoned cruisers who've sailed both lines extensively. Get ready for surprising category winners that challenge common assumptions about these popular cruise destinations.