Orthodox Christianity vs. Catholicism | Rebuttal to Erick Ybarra on Matt Fradd's Pints With Aquinas

In this video, we do a review of the debate Erick Ybarra had with Fr. Patrick Ramsey on ‪@pintswithaquinas‬concerning whether or not the Vatican I Papacy was present in the first millennium Church. Watch our full video on Patreon:   / ubipetrus  

The original debate on Matt Fradd's channel:
   • Orthodox VS Catholic Debate on the Papacy ...  

Our blog is here: https://ubipetrusibiecclesiahome.word...
We would like to thank @Orthodox Pilgrim for the voice work.

-Bibliography and Works Cited --

“Why Catholicism is Wrong on Church History & Erick Ybarra Refuted”:    • Why Catholicism is Wrong on Church History...  

“Pope St. Leo’s Tome, Proof of Infallibility?”    • Видео  

“Papal Forgeries, A Road to Schism”    • Видео  

"All Bishops are Peter"
https://ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2020...

"Does the Lateran Council of 649 Prove Papal Infallibility?" https://ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2020...

"Pope St. Boniface I and Papal Authority" https://ubipetrusibiecclesia.com/2020...
Bibliography & Works Cited:

Benedict, Pope, and Vittorio Messori. "The Ratzinger Report : An Exclusive Interview on the State of the Church." San Francisco, Ignatius Press, 1985.

Booth, P., Cubitt, C., & Price, R. (2017). The Acts of the Lateran Synod of 649 (Translated Texts for Historians LUP) (1st ed.). Liverpool University Press.

Common Christological Declaration of Pope John Paul II and His Holiness Mar Dinkha IV, Catholicos-Patriarch of the Assyrian Church of the East. (1994, November 11). Https://Www.Vatican.va/Content/John-P....

Joint International Commission for the Theological Dialogue between the Orthodox Church and the Roman Catholique Church (2007, October 13). Https://Www.Ecupatria.Org/Documents/J....

Neil, B., & Allen, P. (2014). Pope Gelasius I, The Letters of Gelasius I (492–496): Micro-manager and Pastor of the Church of Rome (Adnotationes: Commentaries on Early Christian and Patristic Texts) (Bilingual ed.). Brepols Publishers.

O’Connor, J. T. (2008). The Gift of Infallibility: The Official Relatio on Infallibility of Bishop Vincent Ferrer Gasser at Vatican Council I (First ed.). Ignatius Press.

Price, R. (2012a&b). The Acts of the Council of Constantinople of 553: With Related Texts on the Three Chapters Controversy (Translated Texts for Historians LUP) (Volume 51) (1st ed.). Liverpool University Press.

Price, R. (2020). The Acts of the Second Council of Nicaea (787) (Translated Texts for Historians LUP). Liverpool University Press.

Price, R., & Gaddis, M. (2007). The Acts of the Council of Chalcedon (Translated Texts for Historians LUP) (Volume 45). LUP.

Price, R., & Graumann, T. (2020). The Council of Ephesus of 431: Documents and Proceedings TTH, LUP.

Price, R., & Whitby, M. (2011). Chalcedon in Context: Church Councils 400 to 700 TTH, LUP.

Schaff, Philiip (Editor); Et Al. (1886). CHURCH FATHERS: Home. New Advent. https://www.newadvent.org/fathers/

Synodality and Primacy During the First Millennium: Towards a Common Understanding in Service to the Unity of the Church (2016, September 21). Https://Www.Ecupatria.Org/Synodality-....

Unless otherwise noted, all patristic and canonical quotations are from the Church Fathers series edited by Philip Schaff found at www.newadvent.com

0:00 Introduction
10:27 The Importance of Gasser's Relatio
14:21 Three Examples of Papal Infallibility in the Relatio
21:51 St. Irenaeus of Lyon
29:29 Excommunications as Local Occurrences
35:01 St. Cyprian of Carthage and Pope St. Stephen
38:26 Council of Sardica and Rome as "Last Court of Appeals"
41:30 Philip the Roman Legate at Ephesus
43:50 The Robber Synod of Ephesus 449
48:35 The Council of Chalcedon and Canon 28
53:46 The LIbellus of Hormisdas
55:59 The Lateran Council of 649 & St. Maximus the Confessor
1:07:00 Pope St. Agatho the 6th Ecumenical Council
1:14:11 Pope Hadrian and the 7th Ecumenical Council
1:16:12 Authority as Auctoritas vs. Potestas
1:19:11 St. Theodore the Studite
1:20:43 Auctoritas in Pastor Aeternus
1:25:48 Primacy vs. Supremacy in the Canons and the Papacy as a Divine Institution
1:35:41 Appeals to Rome
1:46:22 Lateran 649, St. Cyprian of Carthage, and Episcopal Depositions
2:01:08 Dogmatic vs. Ecumenical Councils; Pope Vigilus & the 5th Ecumenical Council
2:04:58 Nestorius in the Catholic Church
2:11:45 Pope Benedict XVI Admits the Orthodox Church is the Authentic Church
2:18:01 Council of Florence and Was Rome a "Bulkwork of Orthodoxy" in the First Millennium?