Best Tent based on specifications and NOT brand name?

Combed through the data on 19 tents from North Face, Sea to Summit, MSR, Durston, Hyperlite Mountain Gear, Big Agnes, Nemo, Gossamer Gear, Zpack and 3 tarps from Kammok, Eno and Grand Trunk.

note: Gore-Tex is typically waterproofing of 28,000 mm. ONLY Hyperlite Mountain Gear and Zpack get close to Gore-Tex waterproofing.

Winner 🏆for inexpensive cost.
✅North Face Storm Break 1: $170

Winners🏆 for tent ⛺waterproofing
✅ Hyperlite Mountain Gear Mid 1: 20,000
✅Zpack Duplex Classic: 20,000mm
✅Durston X-Mid 1: 3500mm
✅Durston X-Mid 2: 3500mm

Winner for price to performance
✅Durston X-Mid 1
✅ Durston X-Mid 2

Winner for most rugged and waterproof tarp 🏆
✅Grand Trunk Air Bivy shelter, $159.96 on sale as of 5/18/25, 2,000mm of waterproofing

tents ⛺

North Face
✅Storm Break 1
✅Storm Break 2

Sea to Summit
✅Alto 1
✅Alto 2
✅Ikos 2
✅Ikos 3

MSR
✅Hubba Hubba 1
✅Hubba Hubba LT 2

Durston
✅X-Mid 1
✅X-Mid 2

Hyperlite Mountain Gear
✅Mid 1

Big Agnes
✅Copper Spur UL1
✅Copper Spur UL2

Nemo
✅Osmo UL1
✅Osmo UL 2

Gossamer Gear
✅The One
✅The Two

Tarps ⭐

Eno
✅Pro Fly Sil Rain Tarp

Grand Trunk
✅Air Bivy Shelter

Kammok
✅Kuhli UL