'Marty Supreme' could be the best Hanukkah movie that doesn't take place around Hanukkah

As far as Jewish filmmakers go, the Safie brothers could well be the GOATs (Greatest Of All Time) when it comes to Jewish sports cinema. One of their earliest collaborations was a 2013 documentary on high school basketball star Lenny Cooke; their breakout feature, Uncut Gems, was a sports-adjacent thriller featuring a Passover Seder with Adam Sandler and Idina Menzel; then younger brother Benny Safdie went on to star in Sandler's Happy Gilmore sequel—another sports film with a Jewish lead character.



Now, in late 2025, the brothers (who are great-nephews of architect Moshe Safdie (https://thecjn.ca/arts-culture/archit...) , for those wondering) have gone their separate ways, each directing their own sports movie. Benny directed The Rock in a biopic of MMA fighter Mark Kerr in The Smashing Machine, while older brother Josh Safdie tapped Jewish actor Timothée Chalamet to play table tennis champion Marty Reisman in Marty Supreme.



While Marty Supreme is slated for a Christmas Day release 2025, the Globe and Mail's film editor, Barry Hertz, just published a review of the Oscar contender (https://www.theglobeandmail.com/cultu...) , in which he says the story "burns with the relentless, fight-for-your-life spirit of the Maccabees.... With apologies to Adam Sandler’s Eight Crazy Nights, Marty Supreme is, thematically and spiritually, the greatest Hanukkah movie ever made." Hertz joins the Menschwarmers to explain his reasoning and how this ping pong epic fits into the larger canon of Jewish cinema.



And before that, the boys chat about Jake Retzlaff leading the Tulane Green Wave to success, and get to the source of an incorrect rumour about the Toronto Blue Jays' Eric Clement being Jewish.



Credits




• Hosts:




James Hirsh and Gabe Pulver




• Producer:




Michael Fraiman




• Music:




Coby Lipovitch (intro),



chēēZ π (https://cheez-p.bandcamp.com/)



(main theme, "



Organ Grinder Swing (https://freemusicarchive.org/music/ch...)



")



Support The CJN




• Follow the podcast on




Twitter @menschwarmers (https://x.com/menschwarmers)




• Subscribe to The CJN newsletter (https://thecjn.ca/newsletters/)


• Donate to The CJN (https://thecjn.ca/donate/)




(+ get a charitable tax receipt)




• Subscribe to Menschwarmers (https://thecjn.ca/menschwarmers)




(Not sure how?



Click here (https://thecjn.ca/arts/podcast-how-to/)



)