WAN SYUKRI JOIN KELAB AHLI KALAM YUNAN

Video ini membincangkan secara ilmiah percanggahan hujah oleh Wan Syukri, khususnya berkaitan penafian jisim, anggota, tempat, jarak, dan hal berkaitan sifat-sifat khabariah. Kritikan difokuskan kepada dakwaan bahawa “akidah laisa” kononnya bukan akidah Ahl al-Sunnah, sedangkan dalam perbahasan yang sama penafian tersebut tetap digunakan dan dipertahankan.

This video offers an academic critique by Pu Faiz of the theological arguments presented by Wan Syukri in a recent debate, focusing on the issue of negation (nafī) in divine attributes, such as corporeality, direction, and spatial limitation. The discussion highlights an internal inconsistency in Wan Syukri’s position: while the doctrine commonly referred to as “ʿaqīdah al-laysa” is publicly rejected and labelled as foreign or “Hellenistic kalām,” the same principles of negation are nonetheless affirmed when pressed in argumentation.

The analysis further examines how Wan Syukri’s denial of corporeality and rejection of literal bodily meanings—particularly in discussions surrounding attributes such as yad (hand)—necessarily involves interpretive reasoning that mirrors the very kalām methodology he criticises. Drawing upon established Sunni theological sources, Pu Faiz argues that such negations are not an imported construct, but a foundational aspect of classical Ahl al-Sunnah theology, firmly grounded in Qur’anic principles such as laysa kamithlihi shayʾ.

The views expressed in this video are intended strictly for scholarly discussion and methodological evaluation. Pu Faiz’s critique addresses theological arguments and positions attributed to Wan Syukri, not personal character, and invites viewers to assess the consistency and coherence of the reasoning presented.