“Gethsemane Showdown - Cynthia Erivo vs Steve Balsamo, Ted Neeley & John Legend”

Who is the King of the Views?

Four incredible voices. One impossible song.
Cynthia Erivo takes on Gethsemane from Jesus Christ Superstar — but how does her breathtaking performance compare to legends Steve Balsamo, Ted Neeley, and John Legend?

As the writer of the Stiles & Drewe Best New Song Award winner, a GRAMMY® voting member, and an internationally respected vocal coach and competition judge, I’ve heard some of the greatest voices on earth — and I’m ready to break down what makes these performances unforgettable.

We’ll dive into vocal technique, emotional delivery, and the artistry needed to master one of Andrew Lloyd Webber’s most demanding songs.

🎭 Whether you’re a musical theatre lover, a Jesus Christ Superstar superfan, or just someone who appreciates powerhouse vocals, you’ll love this deep dive into Gethsemane.

Check out my other reaction videos!    • Listen In Colour With Rachel  

Enjoying the inside scoop on songwriting? We earn only around $0.0004 per stream split between all the songwriters!
Support independent music and buy me a coffee ☕️💜:
https://buymeacoffee.com/RachelWalker...

Timestamps:
00:00 Start
01:17 Prelude and Part 1 - Cynthia Erivo
04:34 Part 1 - Steve Balsamo
06:10 Part 1 - John Legend
07:20 Part 1 - Ted Neeley
08:29 Part 2 - Cynthia Erivo
11:05 Part 3 - Cynthia Erivo
14:02 Part 3 - Steve Balsamo
15:41 Part 3 - John Legend
16:47 Part 3 - Ted Neeley
17:59 Part 4 - Cynthia Erivo
19:45 Part 5 - Cynthia Erivo
21:42 Part 6 - Cynthia Erivo
23:47 Part 5 - Steve Balsamo
24:26 Part 6 - Steve Balsamo
25:36 Part 5 - John Legend
26:49 Part 5 - Ted Neeley
27:52 Part 6 - Ted Neeley
28:52 Part 6 - Cynthia Erivo
29:45 Part 7 - Steve Balsamo
30:06 Part 7 - John Legend
31:07 Part 7 - Ted Neeley
32:40 Part 8 - Cynthia Erivo
33:40 Part 8 - Steve Balsamo
34:23 Part 8 - John Legend
34:43 Part 8 - Ted Neeley
36:03 Finale - Cynthia Erivo
37:46 4 Jesus': Who's Your Favourite?

#CynthiaErivo #JesusChristSuperstar #Gethsemane #VocalCoachReacts #MusicalTheatre #AndrewLloydWebber #SteveBalsamo #TedNeeley #JohnLegend