BYU’s Postseason Problem: The 12-Team CFP Format Locked in & Why the Cougars Face Major Hurdle Again

The College Football Playoff (CFP) has officially confirmed it will maintain the 12-team format for the upcoming 2026 season. While the stability of the bracket is set, the outlook for BYU Football is increasingly urgent. On today’s episode of Locked On Cougars, we discuss why the "status quo" in the CFP is actually a major hurdle for a program that has spent the last two years on the outside looking in.

The 12-Team Ceiling: Why BYU is Still Missing the Cut

As we prepare for the 2026 campaign, the 12-team playoff is no longer a "new" experiment—it is the standard. However, for the Cougars, the last two seasons have served as a painful reminder of the gap between being "good" and being "playoff-caliber." We break down the math:

The "Left Out" Legacy: Looking back at the 2024 and 2025 seasons, we analyze the specific reasons why the selection committee passed over BYU.

The Strength of Schedule Dilemma: How the Big 12's cannibalization is making it harder for BYU to maintain the win-loss record required for an at-large bid.

Is 12 Enough? We discuss the reality that despite the field being larger than the old four-team era, the task of breaking into the top 12 has actually become harder for the Cougars as the elite programs consolidate power.

Listener Mailbag: BYU Basketball (Men’s & Women’s)

The BYU Basketball conversation is heating up as we head into the 2026-27 cycle. Our listeners are asking the tough questions:

The Kevin Young Era: Assessing the current roster’s ability to compete for a Big 12 title and a high seed in the Big Dance.

Women’s Hoops Progress: Has the program made the necessary jump in physicality and depth to challenge the top of the conference?

Roster Retention: How the program is navigating the modern landscape of NIL and the portal to keep their best talent in Provo.

Impact Freshmen: Who Takes the Leap in 2026?

We pivot back to football to identify the potential impact freshmen for the 2026 fall season. If BYU is going to break their playoff drought, they need young stars to contribute early. We highlight Why the 2026 class represents a shift in BYU’s recruiting strategy under Kalani Sitake.

Breaking the Cycle

We wrap up by looking at what it will take for BYU to finally secure a spot in the 2026 12-team field. It isn't just about winning games; it's about dominant performance. Is this the year the Cougars finally kick down the door?